The Department of Justice has issued more than 200 subpoenas in a widening criminal investigation into allegations that Democratic political operatives recruited a second candidate named Dan Sullivan to confuse Alaska voters and weaken the reelection campaign of Republican Senator Dan Sullivan.
The investigation has continued even after Democratic candidate Mary Peltola was declared the winner of Alaska’s November 3 Senate election, bringing renewed scrutiny to an unusual ballot controversy involving two candidates with nearly identical names.
Federal law enforcement sources confirmed November 18 that investigators had issued more than 200 subpoenas while examining the circumstances surrounding Daniel J. Sullivan’s entry into the Senate race.
The candidate, a retired teacher from Petersburg, Alaska, became known as “Decoy Dan” after questions emerged about whether his campaign was intended to draw votes away from the incumbent Republican senator.
The incumbent, Senator Dan S. Sullivan, was seeking another term against Peltola and other candidates in a closely contested election.
The appearance of another Dan Sullivan on the same ballot created an unusual situation that federal authorities are now examining for possible unlawful coordination or other violations.
The investigation has reportedly expanded across multiple states and involves several individuals identified by investigators as potential criminal targets.
According to law enforcement sources, the growing number of subpoenas reflects the effort to obtain communications, financial information, campaign records, and evidence concerning the alleged recruitment operation.
The investigation intensified after reporting revealed discussions among political operatives about what was described as a “ballot composition project.”
That effort allegedly involved identifying a candidate with the same name as the incumbent Republican senator and encouraging him to enter the race.
The central accusation is that the similar name could mislead voters who intended to support the incumbent, creating an advantage for Peltola.
The allegations became especially significant because the Senate election was expected to influence the balance of power in Congress.
The November contest ultimately ended with Peltola defeating Sullivan, becoming one of the first Native American women elected to the United States Senate.
Final reported results showed Peltola receiving 144,302 votes compared with 131,844 for the incumbent Republican senator.
The additional candidate named Dan Sullivan received 4,760 votes, while Republican Gerald Heikes received 6,105.
Those figures establish that the second Sullivan attracted thousands of votes, but they do not establish how those voters would have cast their ballots if he had not been a candidate.
They also do not establish that the additional candidacy changed the winner of the election.
Nevertheless, the circumstances of his recruitment and campaign activities have become central questions in the federal investigation.
The Justice Department began examining the matter before Election Day, initially focusing on whether the second Sullivan’s candidacy was genuine or designed to mislead voters.
The investigation subsequently accelerated when reporting described possible coordination involving Democratic campaign personnel and outside political operatives.
Federal prosecutors issued additional grand jury subpoenas and records-preservation notices as the allegations received greater attention.
The number of investigative demands grew from dozens to more than 120 earlier in November before reportedly exceeding 200 by November 18.
Investigators have also examined possible financial transactions associated with the second Sullivan’s campaign.
The candidate reportedly raised approximately $35,556 despite maintaining a relatively limited public campaign presence.
His campaign activities and financial records may help investigators determine who supported the candidacy and what purpose those supporters intended it to serve.
Attorney Marc Elias, whose law firm has represented Peltola’s campaign, was reportedly among those who received a Justice Department target letter earlier this month.
A target letter indicates that prosecutors consider an individual a potential subject of criminal proceedings, but it does not constitute an indictment or establish guilt.
Other recipients reportedly included political figures and individuals associated with Democratic campaign operations.
Investigators have not publicly announced a final criminal charging decision.
The inquiry has also involved a separate legal dispute over whether Alaska should have delayed certification of the Senate election.
The Justice Department previously sought judicial intervention because of its concerns about the second Sullivan’s presence on the ballot.
A federal judge dismissed the government’s lawsuit after concluding that the proposed legal remedy could not be implemented in the manner requested.
The ruling included concerns about preserving ballot secrecy and the difficulty of determining whether individual voters had been confused by the candidates’ names.
Alaska’s Supreme Court had separately allowed the second Sullivan to remain on the ballot despite challenges to his candidacy.
Those court decisions are significant because they distinguish the legality of ballot access from the separate question of whether any person committed a criminal offense while organizing or financing a campaign.
A candidate’s eligibility to appear on the ballot does not automatically determine whether campaign-related conduct violated criminal law.
Similarly, allegations of coordination do not establish that voters were unlawfully deceived or that election results were manipulated.
President Donald Trump publicly criticized the alleged recruitment operation during the final days of the campaign.
He argued that the presence of two candidates named Sullivan raised serious questions about whether voters were being deliberately misled.